Loading...
Eteach
closeClose Eteach

Candidates keyboard_arrow_down

Jobs
Career Pathways
1
keyboard_arrow_down

Supply Teaching

Register for day-to-day and long-term supply work

Permanent Recruitment

Let our expert find your next role for you

Tutoring Opportunities

Join Education Boutique for online and face-to-face tutoring

International Recruitment

Gain advice and assistance on teaching overseas

Teacher Training

Discover how to get into teaching through approved training providers

ECT Community

Start your career in education as part of a community and receive expert advice

Become an Adviser New

Use your expertise to support schools and colleges

Resources keyboard_arrow_down

CPD

Access valuable resources from our partners to develop your knowledge

Blog

Explore expert advice and tips from your CV to the classroom

FAQs

Find solutions to common questions and concerns quickly and easily

Location Guides

Learn more about what it's like to teach across the globe

Teaching in the UK

Discover what is required to teach in the United Kingdom

Phases

Search jobs by phase

Institution Type

Search jobs by institution type

Curriculum

Understand more about the National Curriculum

Rewards
Sign in

Employers keyboard_arrow_down

Employers Home
Services keyboard_arrow_down

Job Advertising

Advertise teaching jobs, leadership roles and support vacancies to increase your candidate reach

Education Recruitment Software

Manage your hiring process with an applicant tracking system specifically designed for education

Specialist Recruiters

Let our education recruitment consultants search, screen and select the right candidates for you

Education Boutique

Provide in-person and online support for your students with our bespoke tutoring services

Eteach Education Advisers

Receive independent and accredited advice on a wide range of sector-specific areas

Booking System

Search and book vetted, qualified supply teachers using our advanced online booking system

Prices keyboard_arrow_down

Explore Packages

Discover the best solution for your talent management

Instant Job Advert

Pay per vacancy with our instant job advert service for adhoc recruitment

Lite Licence

Access unlimited advertising for a single one-off annual fee

Premium Licence

Utilise the power of our applicant tracking system and unlimited advertising all in one package

Enhancements

Expand your reach through featured job listings, targeted emails and social media campaigns

Advice keyboard_arrow_down

Guides

Benefit from best practice guides on education recruitment and staff retention

Blog

Explore expert advice and tips from leadership to recruitment

Showcases

Find out how we've helped schools like yours succeed

Classroom

Watch free webinars on how to get the most from our products and services

Sign in

About us keyboard_arrow_down

Who we are
Mission and vision
Work for us
Partners
Contact us
MenuMenu
1
search Search
  • account_circleSign in
  • account_circleSign in
  • Jobs
  • Career Pathways 1

    Supply Teaching

    Register for day-to-day and long-term supply work

    Permanent Recruitment

    Let our experts find your next role for you

    Tutoring Opportunities

    Join Education Boutique for online and face-to-face tutoring

    International Recruitment

    Gain advice and assistance on teaching overseas

    Teacher Training

    Discover how to get into teaching through approved training providers

    ECT Community

    Start your career in education as part of a community and receive expert advice

    Become an Adviser New

    Use your expertise to support schools and colleges

  • Resources

    CPD

    Access valuable resources from our partners to develop your knowledge

    Blog

    Explore expert advice and tips from your CV to the classroom

    FAQs

    Find solutions to common questions and concerns quickly and easily

    Location Guides

    Learn more about what it's like to teach across the globe

    Teaching in the UK

    Discover what is required to teach in the United Kingdom

    Phases

    Search jobs by phase

    Institution Type

    Search jobs by institution type

    Curriculum

    Understand more about the National Curriculum

  • Rewards
  • Services

    Job Advertising

    Advertise teaching jobs, leadership roles and support vacancies to increase your candidate reach

    Education Recruitment Software

    Manage your hiring process with an applicant tracking system specifically designed for education

    Specialist Recruiters

    Let our education recruitment consultants search, screen and select the right candidates for you

    Education Boutique

    Provide in-person and online support for your students with our bespoke tutoring services

    Eteach Education Advisers

    Receive independent and accredited advice on a wide range of sector-specific areas

    Booking System

    Search and book vetted, qualified supply teachers using our advanced online booking system

  • Prices

    Explore Packages

    Discover the best solution for your talent management

    Instant Job Advert

    Pay per vacancy with our instant job advert service for adhoc recruitment

    Lite Licence

    Access unlimited advertising for a single one-off annual fee

    Premium Licence

    Utilise the power of our applicant tracking system and unlimited advertising all in one package

    Enhancements

    Expand your reach through featured job listings, targeted emails and social media campaigns

  • Advice

    Guides

    Benefit from best practice guides on education recruitment and staff retention

    Blog

    Explore expert advice and tips from leadership to recruitment

    Showcases

    Find out how we've helped schools like yours succeed

    Classroom

    Watch free webinars on how to get the most from our products and services

  • Search jobssearch

    Search jobs

    Job title
    Mic icon
    close icon
        location
        close
        arrow_drop_down
        search
        Search
      • Candidates
      • Employers
      • account_circleSign in
      • account_circleSign in
      • INSTANT JOB ADVERT

        • Post your vacancy on the UK's leading education job site and start receiving applications today!
        Post a vacancy

        RECRUITMENT SOLUTIONS

        • Want to know more about our recruitment solutions for schools?
        Recruit with Eteach

        WE'LL DO IT FOR YOU

        • Free advertising! Pay per candidate placed and only pay on success.

        Call us: 0845 226 1906

      Job title
      Mic icon
      close icon
          location
          close
          arrow_drop_down

          Mixed ability or setting and streaming?

          Classroom advice
            | August 17, 2018

          Written by Elizabeth Holmes

          • ALL
          • classroom advice
          • career path
          • nqt and graduate advice
          • recruitment advice
          • cv and interview tips
          • in the news
          • wellbeing
          • product updates
          • leadership
          • teaching overseas
          • ect and graduate advice
          < Back to blog

          Too many years ago, when I was completing my PGCE at the Institute of Education in London, I chose to focus on mixed ability teaching for one of the two dissertations I had to complete. It was fascinating to research, especially as all my teaching experience up to that point had been with mixed ability groups. This was more than a quarter of a century ago and the conclusion I drew then was that mixed ability grouping and teaching was by far the best option for the children in my classes. As a teacher, nothing I have ever experienced since has convinced me otherwise. Teach to the top and employ a range of strategies to ensure I bring all students along with me. I got an A for the dissertation and the research I did, and conclusions I drew seem to have served me well since. So was I right? Should schools really be setting and streaming all the way?

          Looking at what has emerged in the research since I completed my dissertation, it seems little has changed. It is a pretty consistent message. For example, the nfer report, Streaming, Setting and Grouping by Ability: a review of the literature (Laura Sukhnandan with Barbara Lee) and the Millennium Cohort Study both make interesting reads but not if you are seeking to anchor your reason for setting or streaming in an evidence base.

          The Education Endowment Foundation has a Setting or Streaming page in its Teaching and Learning Toolkit (March 2018), which is a summary of international evidence on teaching 5-16 year-olds. It concludes that: “Overall, setting or streaming appears to benefit higher attaining pupils and be detrimental to the learning of mid-range and lower attaining learners. On average it does not appear to be an effective strategy for raising the attainment of disadvantaged pupils, who are more likely to be assigned to lower groups.” Clear and persuasive?

          At the British Educational Research Association conference in 2017, this issue was discussed through a paper by academics including Becky Taylor of the UCL Institute of Education. In her view, “Mixed-attainment grouping is widely seen as difficult and unconventional, and therefore risky. It is student attainment outcomes which suffer as a result of this fear.” Yet the small, positive benefits for the very highest attaining pupils should not be overlooked. The key question remains, are those benefits worth the consequences that the remaining pupils, both middle-attaining and low-attaining, must absorb for the sake of the highest attaining, or should we target interventions for the highest attaining in mixed ability groups so that all may benefit? In other words, can we afford to sacrifice the attainment of the many in order to boost, slightly, the attainment of the few?

          It is hard to find evidence in support of segregating children on the grounds of prior attainment, and easy to find evidence not to. And yet setting and streaming remains a popular idea with policy makers and a few educators. According to the National Education Union, “the UK already employs setting to a far greater degree than many other countries – only six per cent of pupils were not “grouped by ability within their math classes” according to the international PISA study on educational outcomes in OECD countries.” Is that concerning given the evidence? Countries such as South Korea and Japan resort to setting to a far lesser degree and yet they both outperform the UK in maths. Staggeringly, though, setting and streaming even goes on in Early Years, despite what we know about how young children learn best. 

          There is no doubt, our relationship with setting and streaming is a curious one in the UK. Perhaps support for it is ideological rather than rational? Or perhaps we need to ask slightly different questions in future research? For example, are we deploying staff to best effect in classes that are set or streamed? At the moment, the message still appears to be loud and clear; mixed ability groups are best for the vast majority of children. If we are tempted to

          Find out more…

          The Education Endowment Foundation report, Setting or Streaming can be found here 

          The EEF Toolkit can be found here 

          See here for more from the NEU on setting and streaming 

          About the author

          Elizabeth Holmes

          After graduating with a degree in Politics and International Relations from the University of Reading, Elizabeth Holmes completed her PGCE at the Institute of Education, University of London. She then taught humanities and social sciences in schools in London, Oxfordshire and West Sussex, where she ran the history department in a challenging comprehensive. Elizabeth specialises in education but also writes on many other issues and themes. As well as her regular blogs for Eteach and FEjobs, her books have been published by a variety of publishers and translated around the world. Elizabeth has also taught on education courses in HE and presented at national and international conferences.

          Share :

           
          Jobseekers
          • Browse jobs
          • Career advice
          • Direct recruiters
          • Blog
          Schools
          • Our services
          • Packages
          • Recruitment advice
          • Case studies
          Eteach
          • About us
          • Contact us
          • Careers
          • Our partners

          About Eteach

          The Eteach Group is an EdTech software and services company, dedicated to providing education recruitment solutions for teachers and support staff to connect directly with schools online and find the latest jobs and opportunities available. To find out more about our mission, visit the About Us page.

          Eteach

          • Who we are
          • Contact us
          • Mission and vision
          • Work for us
          • Partners

          Legal

          • Terms and conditions
          • Privacy policy
          • Cookies
          • Accessibility
          • Carbon reduction plan

          Connect with us

          • Facebook
          • Twitter
          • Instagram
          • tiktok
          • LinkedIn
          • call 0845 226 1906
          • email Send us a message
          • location_on 1 Arlington Square, Bracknell, Berkshire RG12 1WA
          • location_on 33-35 Cathedral Road, Cardiff CF11 9HB
          Education Today

          Legal

          • Terms and conditions
          • Privacy policy
          • Cookies
          • Accessibility
          • Carbon reduction plan
          Education Today

          © Copyright and database rights Eteach UK Limited 2025

          Jobsaware ISO logo Cyber-Essentials-logo
          TOP
          Loading...